Fall Store Hours: 9am-6pm / U-Pick: Closed for Season

Thanksgiving Pies (Pre-Order, 2026)

$22.00

Product Description

Gobble, Gobble! We are pleased to have our Thanksgiving Pie orders online this year. Bring home a special treat for the holidays. Please note that supply is limited and we will close ordering when we sell out.

We are offering the following 10″ pies:

Apple (regular crust)
Dutch Apple (crumb top)
Caramel Apple Walnut
Cherry
Pumpkin
Apple Berry Rhubarb
Strawberry Rhubarb
Peach

*Unfortunately, we will not have Cindy’s Grape Pies this year*

Cost: $22.00
Pick up: Tuesday (11/24) or Wednesday (11/25) from 9am to 6pm

If you would like to order for Monday, Friday, Saturday, or Sunday pick up, please call the store. 585-872-2924.

When you arrive to pick up your pie, head to the Ice Cream counter and check in using your last name.

Additional information

Pick Up Day

Tuesday, 11/24 Pick up, Wednesday, 11/25 Pick up

Pie Variety

Apple, Dutch Apple, Apple Berry Rhubarb, Caramel Apple Walnut, Cherry, Peach, Pumpkin, Strawberry Rhubarb